Pizza restaurants

Great Scotts Pizza

4.3 176 reviews Closed 1437 S Broadway, Santa Maria, CA 93454, United States

Discover this place

Great Scotts Pizza, located at 1437 S Broadway in Santa Maria, CA, is a beloved pizza restaurant with a loyal customer base. Many patrons, like Areli Jimenez, highlight the warmth of the owner, who treats guests like family and has been serving delicious pies for years. The atmosphere resonates with nostalgia, evoking late 70s and early 90s vibes, as noted by visitors like Alexis García, who appreciate the rustic charm and humor of the staff.

Customers rave about the food, particularly the pizza, which many insist is the best in Santa Maria. The fresh ingredients and tasty calzones, as mentioned by Jodie Palmer, ensure a satisfying dining experience. Christina Garcia echoes this sentiment, praising the fantastic customer service, even at closing time. Families can enjoy their meals together while kids play games, making it an ideal dining spot for all.

Overall, Great Scotts Pizza stands out not just for its food but also for its sense of community and warmth, sealing its status as a must-visit destination for locals and travelers alike.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Curbside pickup
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd

College students
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Great Scotts Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Great Scotts Pizza

4.3

176 reviews

100%

22%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 176 reviews

Great Scotts Pizza consistently receives praise for its warm, family-oriented atmosphere and friendly, attentive service, often highlighted by personal interactions with the owner and staff. Reviewers appreciate the nostalgic vibe of the space, which evokes a retro, casual setting that many find inviting. The food quality is commonly described as fresh and flavorful, with particular commendation for their pizza and calzones. While some patrons note that certain aspects like the décor and cleanliness, especially of the restrooms, could be improved, the overall dining experience remains positive. The restaurant’s strong connection to the local community and its appeal as a long-standing neighborhood favorite is a recurring theme, alongside mentions of the accommodating environment for families. Fast delivery and accommodating service even toward closing time contribute to the brand’s favorable reputation among returning customers and first-time visitors alike.

Areli Jimenez

May 16, 2025

The best pizza in Santa Maria. My family and I have been coming here for many many years, since I was really small. The owner is so nice and friendly and treats you like family. Every time I visit Santa Maria I always make sure to stop by for my pizza. Absolutely love this place. So many great memories. Definitely recommend to everyone.

Alexis García

May 16, 2025

Fist time going here and the atmosphere was really welcoming, it gave early 90's late 70's vibes. The food may feel a little cheap but was really good. One employee was really funny and charming, he was very sarcastic and all in all a fun guy. Lots of graffiti and the bathrooms could use some cleaning. I walked in and it immediately gave me a 90's bar feeling, the fireplace was really nice.

Jodie Palmer

May 10, 2025

Excellent service, fast delivery and delicious Calzones! Extra dipping marinara not needed for these but. If you're used to it make sure to order it extra.

S Vargas

Apr 24, 2025

Best pizza in santa maria,been eating there since I was 8 years. That was our spot to eat during lunch time,like 5 min walk from Santa Maria high school.

Christina Garcia

Apr 22, 2025

Their food was fresh. Great customer service. We called 10 minutes before closing time and the owner personally welcomed us to dine in. It was nice to sit with the family. And the kids got to play games which is a big plus ...

Richard Albert (Richard Albert)

Apr 17, 2025

This has been our 'go-to' for pizza, salads, garlic bread, and goodies for longer than I can remember. It's a welcome refuge from obnoxious TVs and other noise makers. Portions are generous without being excessive. Try the All Meat Special. It's the best in the city.

Rolando Flores

Mar 12, 2025

I came here with 4 of my friends including i and there was a older man there around 60s and was completely chill ! Respectful and funny ! came here yesterday as well and a guy with long hair was awesome as well (: always quiet and good pizza !

Jose A.

Mar 10, 2025

The flavor of the pizza is unbeatable. Each slice of pizza melts in your mouth and you can savor all the fresh ingredients and the herbs. You won't find the great taste of pizza like this anywhere else!